Codo, on 2012-January-31, 08:24, said:
If partner bids 4 Spade, he has 5 spades and I will pass. Will not be the end of the world to play a 5-2 fit.
KQxx Jxx Qxx Axx
Partner doubles 3
♣ at imps and your call is?
Anyone who claims that the jump to 4
♠ shows 5 cards in the suit has lived a charmed life.
I'm not disagreeing with the notion that partner will often have a 5 card suit.
I am a 'strong' overcaller, but there are limits...this hand (just) exceeds them. I double and bid 4
♦ over 3
♠ or 3
♦, and 4
♥ over 3
♥. I will bid 5
♥ over an unlikely 4
♣ by partner.
I will raise 3N to 4N
If he does bid 4
♠, well.....what can I do? I have to pass and hope.
The idea of bidding 3N over a 3
♠ advance makes me ill.....where does one find games in which that makes any sense at all? Won't partner be thrilled to lay down Kx or Qxx in clubs....until trick 2, of course.
'one of the great markers of the advance of human kindness is the howls you will hear from the Men of God' Johann Hari