Page 1 of 1
what do u bid? what does gib have?
#2
Posted 2019-April-07, 09:58
What kind of bid is 4♠?
North is a passed hand and is now making a slam try?!
North is a passed hand and is now making a slam try?!
Sarcasm is a state of mind
#7
Posted 2019-April-07, 15:39
That's not a 4♠ bid. 4♠ shows hearts support.
That's maybe a 4♦ bid. If 4♦ is a fit non-jump, then you'll have to pick your poison with pass or 5♦ or dbl. I suppose I would bid 5♦.
Obviously North should have opened. There isn't a convention that says "sorry partner, I was sleeping and forgot to open".
That's maybe a 4♦ bid. If 4♦ is a fit non-jump, then you'll have to pick your poison with pass or 5♦ or dbl. I suppose I would bid 5♦.
Obviously North should have opened. There isn't a convention that says "sorry partner, I was sleeping and forgot to open".
The world would be such a happy place, if only everyone played Acol :) --- TramTicket
#8
Posted 2019-April-07, 22:32
Agreed, a cue shows support. One doesn't start searching for a new suit at the five level, especially with a passed hand. Over a preempt with less than 5 losers and partner had not bid might be an exception to this rule, but this is nowhere near that case. I bid 5♥, the only bid suit and the only possible trump suit.
#9
Posted 2019-April-07, 22:59
fwiw i came out ok on this one. i decided to bid 5d as a cue and the north bot passed. this was a clallenge against bots . at the other table the south bot passed the double and the north bot bid 5d.
but 4s is incomprehensible to me.
but 4s is incomprehensible to me.
#10
Posted 2019-April-08, 11:23
johnu, on 2019-April-07, 13:04, said:
4♠ is a crazy bid. Also, South has opened 3rd hand, not that GIB understands opening light in 3rd seat.
It should be something with pretty wild distribution like
It should be something with pretty wild distribution like
Yes shoud be something like that. But Gib? what are the odds if Thomas posts the actual hand its something like this?
Sarcasm is a state of mind
Page 1 of 1